Reviews
Booklist Review
Set in a grand ballroom, Jane Morris Udovics picture-book debut is narrated
by a boy whos been forced to attend the fancy charity gala his aunt
is throwing. In orderly rhymes, he tells the story of a party gone awry. All
starts out well, if not excitinglythe guests are elegantly dressed,
the punch bowl is flowing, and the boy calls his Aunt Matilda an oh-so-perfect
hostess. But he seems to be on the verge of falling asleep, his eyes sweetly
heavy-lidded. Then both the party and the story go wild: a little dog is on
the loose, a toupee is liberated from a mans head, and custard pies
start flying. Illustrator Udovic choreographs the slapstick comedics with
plenty of verve; the dancers dont mind getting hit by pies, and some
partiers even swing from the chandeliers. Just as the author and illustrator
keep the boy near all the action, so Aunt Matilda is watching out for him.
When he wakes up, theres a giant custard pie at the ready.
Abby Nolan
Kirkus review
In a first-person,
rhyming narration, an unnamed little boy recounts being forced to attend a
party by his Aunt Matilda of the "oh-so-perfect manners" and the
"oh-so-perfect friends." Bored and exhausted, the boy falls asleep
in an armchair and begins to dream. In his dreams, the boring party morphs
into a boisterous free-for-all, in which the guests all wind up throwing pies
at each other. In dreamland, the boy has a change of heart about his Aunt
and invites her to participate in his birthday baseball game. In muted colors
and much detail, the illustrations depict both the real party and the dream
party with the same combination of realism and whimsy. The illustrations also
do the job of clearly indicating with a palette modulation that the boy is
asleep and remains dreaming through the rest of the tale. A pleasing-enough
romp but with an ending somehow unsatisfying, probably because readers know
that the boy's fond memories and new appreciation for Aunt Matilda will vanishrather
undeservedly, as the last scene depicts her lovingly covering him with a blanketwhen
he wakes up. (Picture book. 4-8)
Front Street
"Illustrator
Udovic choreographs the slapstick comedics with plenty of verve; the dancers
dont mind getting hit by pies, and some partiers even swing from the
chandeliers."
School Library Journal